I can only get it to work satisfactorily on 20 meters – on the 20 meter band, I can tune out the reactance with an antenna tuner – coax cable length to the d…

9 replies
  1. WA7PRC
    WA7PRC says:

    Congratulations, you’ve learned the difference between DCR (DC Resistance)
    and AC Impedance. Even if the load resistors aren’t wirewound, a straight
    piece of wire exhibits series inductive reactance at RF. Likely, you have
    capacitive reactance tuning out the inductive reactance at higher
    frequencies, and not enough capacitive reactance to tune it out on lower
    frequencies.

    Even if you get it to play electrically, you still have the issue of
    getting rid of the heat. This design (as is the root Heath pn HN31
    “Cantenna” design) is inefficient in that regard. I see nothing to remove
    the heat from the container. For continuous operation, consider some form
    of liquid-to-air heat exchanger.

    OTOH, I used four 50 Ohm / 400W flange-mount RF resistors on two heatsinks
    for a DL that can handle 1500W at 100% duty cycle as long as the fan is
    blowing (no liquid involved). Cooling was verified using an inexpensive
    LM35DT temperature measurement IC, and a 40.68 MHZ ISM RF power source. My
    design with short connections resulted in VSWR under 1.5:1 thru 54 MHz.
    Reasonably-priced RF power resistors can be found from various vendors on
    ebay.

    Reply
  2. Scubasky
    Scubasky says:

    I don’t know much, but the first thing that comes to mind is you got lucky
    and built it to the right size, and on any other frequency band the
    resonance is causing the signal to be reflected?

    Reply
  3. Jon's Home Workshop
    Jon's Home Workshop says:

    Can’t answer your question, unfortunately, but I do the odd transceiver
    repair and after watching your previous dummy load video, it did cross my
    mind to make one for this work. Definitely watching with interest.

    Something to do with the oil perhaps? I am assuming it is oil filled.

    Jon.

    Reply
  4. TubiCal
    TubiCal says:

    Are you talking about this: 20 m Band (14.000 MHz-14.350 MHz)?

    Then we do some little math here:
    You described your Rc to 47muF, ok as for the Xc it is 1/(2*pi*f*c) is
    aprox 50Ohm correct is 50R – 0.000235Xc (minus 90 degres because the
    reflection will be positive or PreFlexions which i call them;) at 14Mhz….
    For the groundig impedance you´ll have to add 0.01Xc reflection resistance
    to the 50Ohms….(same math as above with 684.5pf without Real R because we
    already know it´s 50Ohms)
    So no reflections nither through the cable nor to ground..

    For full detail we still need Xl so you have to measure the L of this
    thing.May its adding some real amount Xl so it will not cancel out on lower
    frequency or it will may produce more Xl than Xc and will add some
    ringing….

    It´s by far more easier to draw it on a Xl/Xc L/C V/F circle diagram to
    work the whole thing out.

    But for the Xc it works out just fine!

    Have fun! :)

    Reply
  5. Joseph Lorentzen
    Joseph Lorentzen says:

    Wow, you lucked out. I tried so called non inductive wire wound resistors
    to make a dummy load and I know of another dummy load that was made up of a
    whole mess of 1k ohm 5 watt resistors. In both cases, the inductance
    introduced was intolerable and it took a huge capacitor in a homebrewed
    tuner to come anywhere near a fair match. 

    Reply
  6. ElPaso TubeAmps
    ElPaso TubeAmps says:

    After a reasonable amount of work with this dummy load my conclusions are:
    (1) these elements may be rated collectively at 10,500 watts as heater
    elements for water heaters but at 14.2 MHz they can only safely dissipate
    1.5 KW for about 15 minutes before the water (2 gallons) reaches 150 F and
    is boiling around the elements. (2) Obviously, these elements are not made
    for RF and I can only get this dummy load to work satisfactorily, using an
    antenna tuner between the load and the transmitter, on the 20 meter band –
    so… proceed with caution if you build this device and don’t expect it to
    perform like a high quality commercial RF dummy load.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply to TubiCal Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.